The Silence of the Girls

The Silence of the Girls

Book - 2018
Average Rating:
Rate this:
20
1
"The Iliad, as experienced by the captured women living in the Greek camp in the final weeks of the Trojan War"--
Publisher: [London] : Hamish Hamilton, 2018.
Copyright Date: ©2018
ISBN: 9780241338070
Branch Call Number: BARKE
Characteristics: 325 pages ; 25 cm

Opinion

From Library Staff


From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment
JCLAnneG Oct 31, 2020

A look at the Illiad from the viewpoint (mostly) of Briseis, a complex woman who was a Queen of a Trojan tributary and then became a slave/war prize of Achilles. I have never seen a lyrical telling of the gender roles of ancient Greece shown so compelling. We learn about the Greeks and specifically Achilles, Patroclus, and Agamemnon as Briseis does, showing them to be complex flawed humans, not just distant half-gods of ancient myths.

e
esrobbins
Aug 02, 2020

Loved reading this version of The Iliad through the female perspective. I was amazed at the untold story of war and seeing Achilles through different eyes. Briesis is a strong dynamic character.

s
sgcf
Jan 09, 2020

In this re-telling of Homer’s "The Illiad," we are promised the female perspective. During the end stages of the Trojan war, Queen Briseis sees her husband and brothers killed by Achilles before she is awarded to him as a war trophy/sex slave. But I was disappointed that the focus was not on the women – individual characters, their personal histories, how they were dealing with their captivity, a sense of friendship (or not) amongst them. No, it was simply the Trojan War, its key players and camp life as seen through Briseis’ eyes and sensibilities. A ton of gore and slaughter if you’re into that sort of thing.

e
EllenMSmith
Oct 31, 2019

a female slave's view of the Iliad

c
carolwu96
Sep 28, 2019

Patriarchy is not only amongst the Greek gods, but also in the perspectives of the storytellers. We hear about the heroes in the Trojan War, we hear about goddesses and witches taking sides, but what about the mortal women? Casualties of the Trojan War, they become dehumanized, prizes of the victors.⁣

Briseis the protagonist, captured and awarded to Achilles when her city falls to the Greeks, is known as the symbol of honor that causes starts a chain of events in the Iliad. Yet who is she beyond the symbol? ⁣

Pat Barker examines these women and the “heroes” in question. Some women are martyrs, other struck numb, still others fall in love with their captors. Some captors are kind, others loyal, some cowardly. Barker creates characters that keep the reader on her toes, because although she knows their fates, she becomes too attached to them to remain detached.⁣

I cannot help but compare this retelling to Circe, which I just finished 2 days ago. If you look back to my previous post, you will see that I have given its first half 2.5 stars. I had attributed my boredom to the fact that I knew the characters’ endings already, but I still enjoyed The Silence while knowing its ending. I did some further analysis:

- The stories in the first half of Circe are more of a chronology for us to get to know the protagonist. The episodes are loosely related and not explored enough, so the reader is unable to form an attachment to anyone. ⁣

- Circe the character is not developed enough in the first half of the book. She is too passive and while Briseis is also passive, she explains her mindset in detail while Circe just watches.

Anyway, if you are a fan of Greek mythology and retellings, or just want a story on compassion, pain, and humanity, this is your read. Highly recommended. ⁣

For more book reviews and aesthetic pictures, visit me on Instagram @ RandomStuffIRead !

2
2303tes
Sep 04, 2019

Good to have the woman's viewpoint .
Would have helped to have read some background.
Thanks to those who offered a couple of references.

m
mparsons333
Jul 29, 2019

Tells a gripping story and with a voice not heard before

f
finn75
Jun 30, 2019

The illiad's Trojan War from a woman's perspective. As a former royal female Briseis is a prize awarded to legendary warrior Archilles. Her view of the Trojan War from a female slaves perspective is engaging and reminds us that their is more to war than the victor's version of events

f
fionajay
Jun 03, 2019

Nominated for the Women's Prize for Fiction 2019.

j
jeff1885
Jun 03, 2019

Told from the point of view of a captured Queen that was given as reward for battle we are given a look into the camp of the greeks durning the war of Troy. The only part that is odd about this book is that our narrator was in Troy as the battle to retrieve Helen had begun. How'd did she get out? Things of that nature make you think along the way, but you also get a sense that even though captive and fighting against her feelings she does become emotionally attached to the greeks. Even though she rages mentally about how any could fall "in love" with those that took bother her family and burned her city to ash. It is good and give a nice fresh look at an old war.

View All Comments

Summary

Add a Summary
m
meolsen24
Apr 06, 2020

In the same vein as Madeline Miller's "The Song of Achilles," Pat Barker retells the Homeric tale from the perspective of Briseis, the princess of Troy taken as a prize by Achilles. As she narrates the daily interactions with her captor and fellow slaves, it becomes clear to the reader that this is not the romance of rape that has weighed heavily in historic portrayals of the Iliad. The infamous quarrel between Achilles and Agamemnon over her features as the event that drives the story, but this book is primarily a character sketch meant to parallel feminist issues that women still face some three thousand years later.

Age Suitability

Add Age Suitability

There are no age suitabilities for this title yet.

Notices

Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.

Quotes

Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Recommendations

Subject Headings

  Loading...

Find it at OPL

  Loading...
[]
[]
To Top